Biden Administration “Concerned” Over Firing of Defense Minister Gallant Amid War

The Biden administration expressed concern over Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s decision to dismiss Defense Minister Yoav Gallant, with U.S. officials noting that the move, made on the day of the U.S. presidential election, appeared timed to minimize immediate American scrutiny. The White House and Pentagon praised Gallant as a trusted partner, avoiding direct criticism but raising questions about the firing’s timing and motivation, particularly given Israel’s dual security crises.

U.S. Officials Seek Clarity

In a rare show of apprehension, American officials questioned the rationale behind Gallant’s termination. “The surprising decision to fire Defense Minister Gallant is concerning, especially in the middle of two wars and as Israel prepares to defend against a potential attack from Iran,” one U.S. official told The Times of Israel.

Another official suggested that Netanyahu’s decision to act during the U.S. election might be an effort to avoid swift backlash from the Biden administration, which is currently focused on domestic matters.

Pentagon and White House Reactions

Pentagon spokesman Major General Patrick Ryder affirmed that America’s commitment to Israel’s security remains “ironclad.” Meanwhile, a White House National Security Council spokesperson commended Gallant’s contributions to U.S.-Israel defense cooperation and confirmed ongoing support for Israel’s defense priorities under Gallant’s successor, Foreign Minister Israel Katz. However, the spokesperson deferred to the Israeli government on the personnel decision itself.

Gallant’s Role as a Stabilizing Force

Gallant, who had developed a close working relationship with U.S. Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin, was seen as a steadying influence within Israel’s government. Since the onset of Israel’s conflict with Hamas in October 2023, Gallant maintained regular communications with Austin, reportedly holding nearly 100 calls. U.S. officials saw Gallant as a moderating voice in Israel’s war cabinet who acknowledged the need to balance Israel’s military objectives with humanitarian considerations, including aid for Palestinian civilians.

Context of Previous Dismissal and Political Tensions

This is Netanyahu’s second attempt to remove Gallant from the defense post in less than two years. The prime minister previously fired Gallant in March 2023 over his opposition to judicial reforms, a move that the White House condemned at the time, citing concerns about Israel’s internal political stability. After significant public protests, Netanyahu later reversed that decision.